Contraception in Comparison

The Best-Known Methods of Contraception
 

Method:

Pro: Contra:

Ladycomp
Pearl Index 0.6

Natural, well-tolerated, easy to use, no further costs after initial purchase. Very reliable. If desired, can later be equipped with the Babycomp special planning programme. There are a few days a month when abstinence or the use of a condom is necessary.

Babycomp
Pearl Index 0.6

Same as Ladycomp but equipped with a special programme for the planning of a pregnancy.   

Contraceptive pill
Pearl Index 0.1 - 0.9

 

Very reliable. Hormonal influence. Various side-effects. Higher health risk for smokers.

Mini-Pill
Pearl Index 0.4 - 2.5

 

Does not prevent ovulation. Quite reliable. Requires discipline. Even differences of three hours in the time of taking the pill reduce reliability. Hormonal influence.

IUD
Pearl Index 1-3

Can be used for one to three years depending on the model chosen. Quite reliable. Risk of infection and pregnancy in the tube. Painful insertion, regular gynaecological examinations necessary. Not suitable for women who plan to become pregnant later.

Condom
Pearl Index 2-5

No side-effects. Offers protection from AIDS. Can be used to complement Ladycomp/Babycomp during fertile days. Can be seen 85 an interruption to sex play and an intrusion.

Diaphragm
Pearl Index 2-5

No side-effects. Possible complement for Ladycomp/Babycomp. Must be fitted to the individual woman by a doctor Insertion technique must be learned, not very adaptable.

Chemical substance
Pearl Index 9-25

Generally no side-effects.

Must be inserted into the vagina immediately before sexual intercourse.
Occasional itching and inflammation.
Not very reliable.

Three-monthly injections
Pearl Index below 1

Very reliable. High hormone level causes massive interference in the cycle. Often results in irregular menstruation. Not suitable for women who want to have children later.

Traditional temperature method
Pearl Index 2-4

No side-effects, natural. Involves adhering to many rules. Larger margin of error when various methods are used. Prospective interpretation very difficult.
Mucus method This method is time-consuming and requires training. The mucus method is not very reliable or very adaptable as there are 4 different types of mucus and in the case of many women the mucus only appears when it is too late for contraception, i.e. , after ovulation, and continues for an unnecessarily long time. It can be used as an aid to conception.
Sterilisation The list is not complete without mentioning the sterilisation of men and women. In both cases this requires a surgical intervention which normally cannot be reversed.
Pearl Index The reliability of a method of contraception is expressed in the medical profession by the Pearl Index. The Pearl Index indicates how many unwanted pregnancies occur in 100 user years when using a certain method or substance.

Home